[
  {
    "id": "tabaries2026structured",
    "type": "post-weblog",
    "title": "Do Structured Ideation Methods Still Help Frontier Models? A Blind Patent-Rediscovery Study",
    "author": [
      {
        "family": "Tabariès",
        "given": "Alaric"
      }
    ],
    "issued": {
      "date-parts": [
        [
          2026,
          11,
          18
        ]
      ]
    },
    "container-title": "Carnet d'Alaric Tabariès",
    "URL": "https://altab.fr/en/billets/structured-ideation-blind-patent-rediscovery/",
    "abstract": "Many recent tools wrap a structured ideation method (TRIZ, effect catalogues, cross-domain analogy) around a large language model, on the assumption that guiding the model yields better solutions than simply asking it for ideas. We test this assumption with a blind rediscovery protocol. From 24 European and international patent applications published after the stated knowledge cutoffs of the models under test, we derive problem statements from the prior-art section only, and ask whether each approach produces an idea matching the mechanism of the main claim. We compare plain prompting (7 or 30 ideas) with a contradiction-matrix TRIZ procedure, a forced pass over a 255-entry catalogue of physical effects, and function-based analogy with patent search, using Claude Fable 5.2 and GPT-6.1 Sol as solvers and as cross-model judges. No structured method recovers more inventions than plain prompting in any configuration. With GPT-6.1 Sol, two identical 30-idea runs recover 5 and 8 inventions out of 24, while the catalogue and TRIZ recover 6 and 8: the gap between repeated plain runs is as large as the gap between plain prompting and any method. An apparent complementarity of the effect catalogue with one model does not replicate with the other. We also show that problem statements written with access to the full patent inflate rediscovery rates (17 of 24 versus 8 of 24 for the same model). The study is exploratory, with a small sample and LLM judges. We release the protocol, statements, idea lists and verdicts.",
    "language": "en"
  }
]

